Perhaps they can stop returning CPU values for things that aren't CPUs, too... :D
Adam.
Sent from BlueMail
On 29 Nov 2017, 08:34, at 08:34, Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR ybzahr@prodware.fr wrote:
Hello community,
Little update regarding this topic.
Regarding FAN sensors, PR 1324161 has been issued and the SRX platform team is working on a fix for the next patch release. I believe it is due by early January, but no commitment yet.
Regarding Chassis / CPU sensors, a PR will be filled by our SE in order to revamp MIBs for the newest hardware generations.
I will keep you updated.
Best regards.
Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR - Consultant Expert Prodware France T : +33 979 999 000 - F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr _____________________________________________ Web : prodware.fr
De : Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR ybzahr@prodware.fr Date : lundi 27 novembre 2017 à 09:34 À : Observium observium@observium.org Objet : Re: [Observium] SRX4200 FAN status missing
Hi Adam,
You are absolutely correct. There is nothing you can do here as JTAC confirmed MIB currently implemented MIBs can’t be used to retrieve individual components sensors per card.
They have acknowledged that MIBs need updating / revamping to be fully able to monitor new-gen hardware.
At this stage, the only thing I can do is ask for an ER and track the development of this for both :
Chassis sensors,
CPU sensors,
FAN sensors,
I’ll update you with my progress.
Best regards.
De : observium observium-bounces@observium.org au nom de Adam Armstrong adama@observium.org Répondre à : Observium observium@observium.org Date : dimanche 26 novembre 2017 à 11:28 À : "observium@observium.org" observium@observium.org Objet : Re: [Observium] SRX4200 FAN status missing
Your device is only exposing two temperature sensors in SNMP. They are both being detected and polled.
If you find any other sensors, we can add them, but the sensor you are referring to is not a new sensor, it is just node0 routing engine.
adam.
Adam Armstrong
Managing Director & Lead Architect
Observium Limited
On 2017-11-26 10:21:52, Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR ybzahr@prodware.fr wrote:
Hello Mike,
So how come I can’t see rear-chassis Temp ?
Best regards.
Le 26 nov. 2017 à 11:19, Mike Stupalov mike@observium.org a écrit :
This OIDs already polled in observium, read 4 mails before..
jnxOperatingDescr.9.1.0.0 = node0 Routing Engine jnxOperatingDescr.9.2.0.0 = node1 Routing Engine jnxOperatingTemp.9.1.0.0 = 29 jnxOperatingTemp.9.2.0.0 = 21
Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR wrote:
Hello,
Ok, it is aligned with what JTAC said (see attached).
Basically, old MIBs covering old gen hardware have been re-used for new gen hardware. So, it needs revamping in order to take into consideration all the new components.
In regards with chassis temp, Observium already polls values for Front-chassis temp. Rear-chassis temp can also be polled using the following OID :
SRX4200 :
{primary:node0}
root> show snmp mib walk jnxOperatingDescr
jnxOperatingDescr.1.1.0.0 = node0 midplane
jnxOperatingDescr.2.1.1.0 = node0 Power Supply 0 @ 0/0/*
jnxOperatingDescr.2.1.2.0 = node0 Power Supply 1 @ 0/1/*
jnxOperatingDescr.7.1.0.0 = node0 FPC: FEB @ 0/*/*
jnxOperatingDescr.8.1.1.0 = node0 PIC: 8x10G-SFP @ 0/0/*
jnxOperatingDescr.9.1.0.0 = node0 Routing Engine
jnxOperatingDescr.9.1.1.0 = node0 USB Hub
{primary:node0}
root> show snmp mib walk jnxOperatingTable | match temp
jnxOperatingTemp.1.1.0.0 = 0
jnxOperatingTemp.2.1.1.0 = 0
jnxOperatingTemp.2.1.2.0 = 0
jnxOperatingTemp.7.1.0.0 = 0
jnxOperatingTemp.8.1.1.0 = 0
jnxOperatingTemp.9.1.0.0 = 31 ⇐
jnxOperatingTemp.9.1.1.0 = 0
{primary:node0}
root> show chassis routing-engine | match te
Temperature 31 degrees C / 87 degrees F
SRX5800 :
{primary:node1}
root@F07-01> show snmp mib walk jnxOperatingDescr | match engine
jnxOperatingDescr.9.1.0.0 = node0 Routing Engine 0
jnxOperatingDescr.9.2.0.0 = node0 Routing Engine 1
jnxOperatingDescr.9.3.0.0 = node1 Routing Engine 0
jnxOperatingDescr.9.4.0.0 = node1 Routing Engine 1
{primary:node1}
root@F07-01> show snmp mib walk jnxOperatingTable | match temp | match 9
jnxOperatingTemp.9.1.0.0 = 32 ⇐
jnxOperatingTemp.9.2.0.0 = 0
jnxOperatingTemp.9.3.0.0 = 34 ⇐
jnxOperatingTemp.9.4.0.0 = 0
{primary:node1}
root@F07-01> show chassis routing-engine | match temp
Temperature 32 degrees C / 89 degrees F
CPU temperature 29 degrees C / 84 degrees F
Temperature 34 degrees C / 93 degrees F
CPU temperature 30 degrees C / 86 degrees F
I’ll keep you updated regarding FAN (state / RPM speed) advancements.
Have a nice WE.
Best regards.
Le 25/11/2017 13:28, « observium au nom de Mike Stupalov » <observium-bounces@observium.org au nom de mike@observium.org> a écrit :
Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR wrote:
Hello Mike,
In regards to what I just learned from JTAC, that is normal.
What about the rest of the missing sensors (back chassis temp, CPU temp) ?
I said exactly about sensors too!
No such sensors in walk output!..
Best regards.
Le 25 nov. 2017 à 11:59, Mike Stupalov <mike@observium.org
mailto:mike@observium.org> a écrit :
Ok, I re-read full walk for your device
and still not found any additional sensors with Fans and Temps (except
those already discussed).
Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR wrote:
Hello community,
Regarding the FAN sensors state (status / speed), JTAC confirmed MIB
are missing for the newest hardware gen. They have opened a PR
1324161 to track it (see attached).
That leaves us with the rest of the missing sensors :
Back chassis temp
CPU temp
Mike, were you able to analyze the traces I sent you ?
Best regards.
Le 24/11/2017 09:31, « Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR »
<ybzahr@prodware.fr mailto:ybzahr@prodware.fr> a écrit :
Hello Mike,
Your last email didn’t mention that, doesn’t matter.
Requested outputs can be found here :
https://dl.prodware.org/zljh (password : observium)
Please note that for the second OID, device times out :
root@prod-monit-002:/opt/observium# snmpbulkwalk -v 2c -c XYZ -On
fw01-par01 .1.3.6.1.4.1.2636 > snmpbulkwalk-1361412636.txt
Timeout: No Response from fw01-par01
Waiting for your feedback.
Best regards.
Le 24/11/2017 08:16, « observium au nom de Mike Stupalov »
<observium-bounces@observium.org
mailto:observium-bounces@observium.org au nom de
mike@observium.org mailto:mike@observium.org> a écrit :
Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR wrote:Hello Mike,
What is your take on this ?
About what? You did not send the information I wrote (please re-read myprevious mail).
... Pls send me another full walk from device, I will try to findif here
exist another Oids with Temp. 2 commands: snmpbulkwalk -v2c -c <community> -On <host> .1.3.6.1.2.1 snmpbulkwalk -v2c -c <community> -On <host> .1.3.6.1.4.1.2636Best regards.
Le 23 nov. 2017 à 10:57, Mike Stupalov <mike@observium.org
mailto:mike@observium.org> a écrit :
Wheel..
Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR wrote:
Hello Adam,
It appears I got mixed up copying the wrong email output. That is
what
happens when you do it while you are mobile and in between things.
My bad.
So let’s take a step back here :
_1/ regarding CPU temps :_
You are right about those two objects
(.1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.1.0.0 /
.1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.2.0.0), they are being queried
correctly and match with Chassis Temp1 - Front :
https://apps.juniper.net/mib-explorer/search.jsp#object=1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1...
<https://apps.juniper.net/mib-explorer/search.jsp#object=1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1...
<https://apps.juniper.net/mib-explorer/search.jsp#object=1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1...
<https://apps.juniper.net/mib-explorer/search.jsp#object=1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1...
What is missing here are the following highlighted entries in
Yellow :
root@fw01-par01> show chassis environment
node0:
Class Item Status Measurement
Power FPC 0 Power Supply 0 OK
FPC 0 Power Supply 1 OKTemp System Temp1 - Front OK 30 degrees C / 86
degrees F
System Temp2 - Back OK 40 degrees C /104 degrees F
CPU0 Temp OK 70 degrees C /158 degrees F
CPU1 Temp OK 61 degrees C /141 degrees F
Fans FPC 0 Fan Tray 0 OK Spinning at
normal speed
FPC 0 Fan Tray 1 OK Spinning at normalspeed
FPC 0 Fan Tray 2 OK Spinning at normalspeed
FPC 0 Fan Tray 3 OK Spinning at normalspeed
I believe the rest of those entries can be found in the same MIB.
If I
poll the whole MIB, I do get results (see attached file). Is that
something you can add on your end ?
Ok, I not see "CPUX Temp" entries inside jnxOperatingTemp Oid,
here only:
jnxOperatingDescr.9.1.0.0 = node0 Routing Engine
jnxOperatingDescr.9.2.0.0 = node1 Routing Engine
jnxOperatingTemp.9.1.0.0 = 29
jnxOperatingTemp.9.2.0.0 = 21
which I not sure correctly corresponded with system temp X, since here
different values against from device CLI.
Another temp sensors which I see:
jnxFruName.9.1.0.0 = node0 Routing Engine
jnxFruName.9.2.0.0 = node1 Routing Engine
jnxFruTemp.9.1.0.0 = 30
jnxFruTemp.9.2.0.0 = 21
jnxFruType.9.1.0.0 = routingEngine
jnxFruType.9.2.0.0 = routingEngine
but this is exactly same as in jnxOperatingTemp.
Pls send me another full walk from device, I will try to find if here
exist another Oids with Temp.
2 commands:
snmpbulkwalk -v2c -c <community> -On <host> .1.3.6.1.2.1
snmpbulkwalk -v2c -c <community> -On <host> .1.3.6.1.4.1.2636
_2/ regarding FAN status / spinning speed :_
I was able to confirm with JTAC the correct MIB, it can be found
here :
https://apps.juniper.net/mib-explorer/search.jsp#object=jnxSRX4200SlotFan&am...
<https://apps.juniper.net/mib-explorer/search.jsp#object=jnxSRX4200SlotFan&am...
<https://apps.juniper.net/mib-explorer/search.jsp#object=jnxSRX4200SlotFan&am...
<https://apps.juniper.net/mib-explorer/search.jsp#object=jnxSRX4200SlotFan&am...
I tried with jnxSRX4200SlotFan or 1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.1.1.2.2.143.4, I
don’t get any answers from the device :
root@prod-monit-002:~# snmpwalk -v 2c -c asp fw01-par01
1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.1.1.2.2.143.4
SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.1.1.2.2.143.4 = No Such Object available
on this agent at this OID
Or
root@fw01-par01> show snmp mib walk ascii jnxSRX4200SlotFan
root@fw01-par01> show snmp mib walk ascii
1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.1.1.2.2.143.4
I’m having JTAC check the status of the MIB implantation. I’ll keep
you updated.
Best regards.
*Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR* - Consultant Expert
Prodware France
T : +33 979 999 000 - F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr
Web : prodware.fr http://prodware.fr http://prodware.fr
http://twitter.com/Prodware/ http://www.facebook.com/Prodware/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/prodwarefrance
https://www.youtube.com/c/ProdwareFrance
http://www.viadeo.com/fr/company/prodware
http://www.prodware.fr/social-network/
*De : *observium <observium-bounces@observium.org
mailto:observium-bounces@observium.org
mailto:observium-bounces@observium.org> au nom de Adam
Armstrong <adama@observium.org mailto:adama@observium.org
*Répondre à : *Observium <observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org>
*Date : *mercredi 22 novembre 2017 à 22:47
*À : *"observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org"
<observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org>
*Objet : *Re: [Observium] SRX4200 FAN status missing
Both of those sensors are polled:
CMD[/usr/bin/snmpget -v2c -c *** -Pu -OQUsn -M /opt/observium/mibs
'udp':'fw01-par01':'161' .1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.1.0.0
.1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.2.0.0]
CMD EXITCODE[0]
CMD RUNTIME[0.0178s]
STDOUT[
.1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.1.0.0 = 29
.1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.2.0.0 = 21
]
SNMP STATUS[TRUE]
DescrClass
TypeOrigin
ValueEvent
Last Changed
node0 Routing Engine temperaturejunos
snmp29C
ok2017-02-02 11:40:44
node1 Routing Engine temperaturejunos
snmp21C
ok2017-10-01 07:00:02
adam.
Adam Armstrong
Managing Director & Lead Architect
Observium Limited
On 2017-11-22 21:43:53, Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR
<ybzahr@prodware.fr mailto:ybzahr@prodware.fr
mailto:ybzahr@prodware.fr> wrote:
I’m not seeing them in the device page.
Moreover, no mention at all in the poller output in debug output I
provided with my initial email.
What kind of trace do you want me to run ?
Best regards.
Le 22 nov. 2017 à 22:22, Adam Armstrong <adama@observium.org
mailto:adama@observium.org> a écrit :
The process of collecting temperature sensors from this table certainly works for me. The only requirement in the code seems to be that the value returned isn't zero. Are you /sure/ these sensors aren't being discovered? adam. Adam Armstrong CEO & Lead Architect Observium Limited On 2017-11-22 21:14:23, Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR <ybzahr@prodware.fr <mailto:ybzahr@prodware.fr>mailto:ybzahr@prodware.fr> wrote:
CPUs temps (2x units) from race node : root@fw01-par01> show chassis environment node0:
Class Item Status Measurement Power FPC 0 Power Supply 0 OK FPC 0 Power Supply 1 OK Temp System Temp1 - Front OK 29 degrees C / 84 degrees F System Temp2 - Back OK 39 degrees C / 102 degrees F CPU0 Temp OK 70 degrees C / 158 degrees F CPU1 Temp OK 61 degrees C / 141 degrees F Best regards. Le 22 nov. 2017 à 21:53, Adam Armstrong <adama@observium.org <mailto:adama@observium.org>mailto:adama@observium.org> a écrit :
What is the inventory entry referred to by the indexes 9.1.0.0 and 9.2.0.0? We should definitely already see temperatures fromhere.
BTW, i honestly tend to ignore walks without MIBs loaded. I can easily work out what a numerical OID is from the text, but it's not so useful the other way. adam. Adam Armstrong CEO & Lead Architect Observium Limited On 2017-11-22 19:29:22, Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR <ybzahr@prodware.fr <mailto:ybzahr@prodware.fr>wrote: Hi, From Observium box, there you go : root@prod-monit-002:~# snmpwalk -v 2c -c asp fw01-par01 1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.4.1.2 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.4.1.2 = No Such Object available on this agent at this OID ⇒No answer regarding FANs. root@prod-monit-002:~# snmpwalk -v 2c -c asp fw01-par01 1.3.6.1.4.1.2636.3.1.13.1.7 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.1.1.0.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.1.2.0.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.2.1.1.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.2.1.2.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.2.2.1.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.2.2.2.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.7.1.0.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.7.2.0.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.8.1.1.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.8.2.1.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.1.0.0 = Gauge32: 29 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.1.1.0 = Gauge32: 0 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.2.0.0 = Gauge32: 23 SNMPv2-SMI::enterprises.2636.3.1.13.1.7.9.2.1.0 = Gauge32: 0 ⇒Answers are returned regarding CPU temps. Best regards. Le 22/11/2017 20:23, « observium au nom de Michael » a écrit : Youseff, By now you should know that there can be a world of difference between what the cli of a device can tell you and what it actually presents out the snmp stack. Try running the queries to the oids from a remote host (such as from your observium box). If it doesn't respond to the queries, there's not much that can be done. Michael On 23 November 2017 6:02:39 AM AEDT, Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR wrote: BENGELLOUN - ZAHR Youssef - Consultant Expert Prodware France T : +33 979 999 000 F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr <mailto:ybzahr@prodware.fr>Web : prodware.fr <http://prodware.fr>*Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR* - Consultant Expert Prodware France T : +33 979 999 000 - F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr <mailto:ybzahr@prodware.fr>
Web : prodware.fr <http://prodware.fr> <http://prodware.fr><http://twitter.com/Prodware/> <http://www.facebook.com/Prodware/> <https://www.linkedin.com/company/prodwarefrance> <https://www.youtube.com/c/ProdwareFrance> <http://www.viadeo.com/fr/company/prodware> <http://www.prodware.fr/social-network/>*Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR* - Consultant Expert
Prodware France
T : +33 979 999 000 - F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr
Web : prodware.fr http://prodware.fr http://prodware.fr
http://www.facebook.com/Prodware/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/prodwarefrance
https://www.youtube.com/c/ProdwareFrance
http://www.viadeo.com/fr/company/prodware
http://www.prodware.fr/social-network/
*Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR* - Consultant Expert
Prodware France
T : +33 979 999 000 - F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr
Web : prodware.fr http://prodware.fr http://www.prodware.fr
http://twitter.com/Prodware/ http://www.facebook.com/Prodware/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/prodwarefrance
https://www.youtube.com/c/ProdwareFrance
http://www.viadeo.com/fr/company/prodware
http://www.prodware.fr/social-network/
BENGELLOUN - ZAHR Youssef - Consultant Expert
Prodware France
T : +33 979 999 000 F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr
Web : prodware.fr http://prodware.fr
BENGELLOUN - ZAHR Youssef - Consultant Expert
Prodware France
T : +33 979 999 000 F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr
Web : prodware.fr
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org
<mailto:observium@observium.org>http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
_______________________________________________ observium mailing list observium@observium.orgmailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org
<mailto:observium@observium.org> http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium _______________________________________________ observium mailing list observium@observium.orgmailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org
<mailto:observium@observium.org> http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium _______________________________________________ observium mailing list observium@observium.orgmailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium _______________________________________________ observium mailing list observium@observium.org <mailto:observium@observium.org>mailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
--
Mike Stupalov
Observium Limited, http://observium.org
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
mailto:observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
-- Mike Stupalov Observium Limited, http://observium.org _______________________________________________ observium mailing list observium@observium.org <mailto:observium@observium.org> http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
--
Mike Stupalov
Observium Limited, http://observium.org
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org mailto:observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
*Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR* - Consultant Expert
Prodware France
T : +33 979 999 000 - F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr
Web : prodware.fr http://www.prodware.fr
http://twitter.com/Prodware/ http://www.facebook.com/Prodware/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/prodwarefrance
https://www.youtube.com/c/ProdwareFrance
http://www.viadeo.com/fr/company/prodware
http://www.prodware.fr/social-network/
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
--
Mike Stupalov
Observium Limited, http://observium.org
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
observium mailing list
observium@observium.org
http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
-- Mike Stupalov Observium Limited, http://observium.org
observium mailing list observium@observium.org http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
Youssef BENGELLOUN - ZAHR - Consultant Expert Prodware France T : +33 979 999 000 - F : +33 988 814 001 - ybzahr@prodware.fr
Web : prodware.fr
observium mailing list observium@observium.org http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium