What determines a devices' uniqueness?
Hi All,
We're currently evaluating observium as a our main network monitoring tool. We're using Observium CE 0.16.10.8128 and wondering how observium determines a device as unique?
We currently have the same switch added twice (via auto discovery) into observium and wondered why observium didn't detect it as the same device.
Thanks for a wonderful tool!
Kind regards,
Seb Harrington Network Team Lead, IT Services, University of Sussex,
There are a few more things than just the hostname (like sysName, snmpEngineID) ... However there seem to be a few cases where we don't correctly identify a device being already known. Until now we haven't been able to pinpoint why that is...
Tom
On 21/11/2016 17:28, Sebastian Harrington wrote:
Hi All,
We're currently evaluating observium as a our main network monitoring tool. We're using Observium CE 0.16.10.8128 and wondering how observium determines a device as unique?
We currently have the same switch added twice (via auto discovery) into observium and wondered why observium didn't detect it as the same device.
Thanks for a wonderful tool!
Kind regards, Seb Harrington Network Team Lead, IT Services, University of Sussex,
observium mailing list observium@observium.org http://postman.memetic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/observium
There is no GUID in most devices, so if i have three ip numbers on one device, that resolve to three dns entries, then it will appear as three devices.
until O/S (linux, etc) and built-in firmware get the concept of a GUID for a device, it will be hard.
A few solutions :
Technical approach : Have a facility where an ip address can be banned/blocked. Have a system where duplicate devices can be selected and merged. This means when you click on any three (in the above example) hostnames, you always get the same device record. This would need to show all three (in the above example) hostnames so people know what is happening.
Management approach : on the obs server, edit hosts file for one of the duplicate hostname/ip address and set it to something stupid that will never ping (for me on my network, 192.168.1/24 would work cause i'm on a 10/8 network).
thanks
Peter Hine Senior Technical Support Engineer (Servers) Corporate Services | Federal Court of Australia
********************************************************************** The information contained in this e-mail (including any attachments) is for the exclusive use of the addressee. If you are not the intended recipient please notify the sender immediately and delete this e-mail. It is noted that legal privilege is not waived because you have read this e-mail. **********************************************************************
participants (3)
-
Peter.Hine@familycourt.gov.au
-
Sebastian Harrington
-
Tom Laermans